LLC for Day Trading: Choosing the Right Business Structure to Optimize Taxes

Here’s a question most traders ignore until it’s too late: How much of your hard-earned trading profit are you handing over to the IRS simply because you never bothered to think about your business structure?

Our team has watched this play out hundreds of times. A trader grinds through the learning curve, finally becomes consistently profitable, and then gets absolutely hammered at tax time because they’re still trading as a regular individual—paying the maximum possible tax rate on every dollar.

Look, we get it. When you’re focused on chart patterns, risk management, and execution, the last thing you want to think about is LLCs, S-Corps, and entity formation. But here’s the brutal reality: the difference between trading as a sole proprietor versus structuring your operation correctly can easily mean $10,000, $20,000, or even $50,000+ in annual tax savings.

This guide cuts through the confusion. We’re going to walk you through every business structure option available to day traders—from the simplest (sole proprietorship) to the most tax-advantageous (S-Corporation)—and show you exactly when each one makes sense based on your income, goals, and complexity tolerance. We’ll also cover the step-by-step formation process, annual compliance requirements, and the common (expensive) mistakes traders make when setting up entities.

This isn’t generic small business advice. This is a trader-specific playbook built on IRS guidelines, court precedents, and real-world experience from our team and the top trader tax CPAs in the industry.

One critical note before we begin: forming an entity doesn’t magically create tax benefits. You must first qualify for Trader Tax Status (TTS) based on your trading activity. The entity is simply the vehicle that lets you maximize those benefits. If you haven’t reviewed TTS yet, start there.

Why Your Business Structure Actually Matters (And It’s Not What You Think)

Most new traders assume business structure is just about “looking professional” or getting some vague liability protection. Wrong. For day traders, your entity choice directly impacts three massive financial outcomes: your tax bill, your ability to deduct expenses, and your access to health insurance and retirement plan benefits.

The Real Cost of Ignoring Entity Planning

Let’s say you’re a profitable trader making $100,000 in net trading income. As a sole proprietor—which is what you are by default if you do nothing—you’re missing out on several key advantages. But here’s the kicker: if you formed an S-Corporation and paid yourself a reasonable salary of $60,000 with the remaining $40,000 as distributions, you’d avoid roughly $6,000 in self-employment-equivalent taxes on those distributions (though trading income isn’t technically subject to SE tax, the S-Corp structure still provides payroll tax savings on distributions versus W-2 wages).

That’s not a typo. Six thousand dollars. Every year. Just by checking a different box on your tax forms and running a basic payroll.

And that’s just the salary-distribution split. We haven’t even talked about deducting your $15,000 in annual health insurance premiums, contributing $30,500 to a Solo 401(k) (which you can’t do as a sole proprietor because trading income isn’t “earned income”), or avoiding the $10,000 SALT deduction cap if you live in a high-tax state.

What “Trading as a Business” Really Means

Here’s where traders get tripped up. You can’t just form an LLC, print some business cards, and start claiming massive tax deductions. The IRS has specific guidelines for what qualifies as a “trader in securities” under their rules.

According to IRS Topic No. 429, to qualify for Trader Tax Status, your activity must be substantial (think 4+ trades per day), frequent (trading nearly every market day), and continuous (no months-long gaps). You must seek profit from short-term market movements, not long-term appreciation. And you need to devote significant time to your trading business—generally 4+ hours daily during market hours.

The entity doesn’t create TTS. Your trading activity does. The entity is what allows you to take full advantage of TTS benefits once you’ve already qualified.

If you’re not yet qualifying for TTS, forming an entity is premature. Get profitable first, establish a consistent trading pattern, then revisit entity formation. We’ve seen too many new traders burn money on entity setup fees and annual compliance costs before they’ve even made their first dollar.

Option 1: Sole Proprietorship (Schedule C) – The Default Path

If you’ve never filed any entity paperwork, congratulations—you’re a sole proprietor. This is the simplest structure, and for many traders, it’s where you’ll start (and possibly stay if your income remains modest).

How Sole Proprietorship Works for Traders

When you qualify for TTS as an individual trader, you file your business expenses on Schedule C (Profit or Loss From Business) as part of your Form 1040. Your trading gains and losses are still reported on the appropriate tax forms (Form 8949, Schedule D, or Form 4797 if you’ve elected Mark-to-Market accounting), but your business expenses—things like software subscriptions, market data feeds, and your home office—get deducted on Schedule C.

There’s no formation required. No state registration. No separate tax return. You use your Social Security number for everything, and you’re done.

The Pros: Simplicity and Zero Setup

The appeal here is obvious:

• No formation costs: You don’t pay a single dollar to operate this way
• No annual state fees: There are no LLC franchise taxes or annual reports
• Simple tax filing: Schedule C is straightforward, and most CPAs can handle it without specialized knowledge
• No separate bank account required: Though we strongly recommend one for clean record-keeping

For part-time traders, those with small accounts, or anyone still in the learning/paper trading phase, sole proprietorship makes perfect sense. The complexity of an entity simply isn’t justified when you’re making $10,000 or $20,000 a year.

The Cons: Maximum Tax Exposure

Here’s what you give up:

• No liability protection: Your personal assets (house, car, savings) are exposed if something goes catastrophically wrong in your trading business
• Limited deduction opportunities: You can’t deduct health insurance premiums based on trading income (it’s not earned income), and you can’t make retirement plan contributions unless you have other earned income
• No salary-distribution split: This is where the real S-Corp tax savings come from, and sole proprietors don’t get access to it

The biggest limitation? You cannot create earned income from trading. Trading income is classified as “unearned income” by the IRS, which means you can’t fund a Solo 401(k) or take certain above-the-line deductions unless you structure differently.

Who Should Stay a Sole Proprietor?

You’re fine staying a sole proprietor if:

• You’re making less than $50,000 in annual net trading income
• You’re part-time and have a day job that provides health insurance and retirement benefits
• You’re new to trading and not yet consistently profitable
• You don’t want to deal with any additional paperwork or compliance

Once your income crosses $50,000—and especially once you hit $75,000+—the math starts to shift dramatically in favor of entity formation.

Option 2: Single-Member LLC (SMLLC) – Asset Protection Without Complexity

A Single-Member LLC is the first step up from sole proprietorship. It gives you a legal shield between your personal assets and your trading business, but from a tax perspective, it’s treated almost identically to a sole proprietor.

What is a Single-Member LLC?

An SMLLC is what the IRS calls a “disregarded entity.” In plain English, that means the IRS ignores the LLC for tax purposes and treats you as if you’re still a sole proprietor. You still file Schedule C. You still report trading income the same way. The only difference is you now have a legally separate entity that owns your trading business.

You form an SMLLC by filing Articles of Organization with your state (usually a one-page form and a filing fee ranging from $40 to $500 depending on your state). You get an Employer Identification Number (EIN) from the IRS—a free process that takes 10 minutes online—and you open a business bank account in the LLC’s name.

The Liability Protection Advantage

So why bother? Asset protection.

If you’re trading with significant leverage, using margin aggressively, or hiring employees to help with research or admin tasks, an LLC creates a legal barrier. If something goes wrong—a lawsuit, a massive margin call you can’t cover, a contractual dispute with a vendor—the creditor can generally only go after the LLC’s assets, not your personal house or savings.

Now, let’s be realistic. Most day traders aren’t facing major liability risks. You’re not running a factory or a construction company. But there are scenarios where protection matters:

• You’re using 4:1 or 6:1 margin regularly
• You’ve hired contractors or employees (and might face employment claims)
• You’re leasing commercial office space or co-locating trading servers with brokers
• You’re planning to eventually elect S-Corp status (it’s easier to convert an existing LLC than form a corporation later)

Tax Treatment: Almost Identical to Sole Proprietor

From a tax perspective, there’s basically no difference. You still file Schedule C. You still can’t deduct health insurance or fund a Solo 401(k) based on trading income. You still don’t get the salary-distribution split.

The only tax change? If you live in a state with annual LLC fees—like California’s infamous $800 annual franchise tax—you’ll owe that every year. So you’re paying for liability protection and the optionality of future S-Corp election, not for current-year tax savings.

The Hidden Catch: Professional Data Rates

Here’s something most articles won’t tell you: entities often pay higher rates for market data.

If you’re using real-time data feeds from exchanges, many providers charge individual “non-professional” rates (which are cheaper) and business “professional” rates (which are higher—sometimes 2x to 3x more expensive). When you register your data feeds under an LLC or corporation, you might get bumped to professional rates.

This doesn’t apply to everyone. If you’re using a broker-provided platform like Thinkorswim (which includes data in your account), you’re fine. But if you’re subscribing to Level II data, premium feeds from Nasdaq or NYSE, or specialized platforms that charge per data package, check the fine print before you form an entity.

For most traders, the cost difference is $50-$200/month. Annoying, but not a deal-breaker if you’re saving thousands in taxes through entity structuring.

When an SMLLC Makes Sense

Form an SMLLC if:

• You want basic asset protection but aren’t ready for S-Corp complexity
• You’re profitable ($30,000+ income) and want to start “looking like a business” to brokers and vendors
• You plan to hire contractors or employees down the line
• You want to open the door to future S-Corp election (you can convert the SMLLC to S-Corp status later with a simple election)
• You’re using significant leverage or margin

Don’t form an SMLLC if:

• You’re making under $25,000/year (the annual state fees may cost more than it’s worth)
• You have no employees, no leverage, and no real liability concerns
• You live in an expensive LLC state like California and don’t need the protection yet

Option 3: Limited Liability Company Taxed as Partnership

This is where things get more sophisticated. A multi-member LLC (meaning two or more owners) is taxed as a partnership by default. For traders, the most common setup is a spousal LLC—you and your spouse are both members, even if only one of you is actively trading.

How Multi-Member LLCs Work for Traders

Instead of Schedule C, a partnership files Form 1065 (U.S. Return of Partnership Income). The partnership itself doesn’t pay taxes—it’s a “pass-through entity”—but it issues Schedule K-1 forms to each partner showing their share of the income, deductions, and credits. You then report your K-1 amounts on your personal Form 1040.

Only one partner needs to qualify for TTS. If you’re the active trader and your spouse has zero trading activity, that’s fine—the entity as a whole qualifies as long as the trading activity is substantial.

From a tax perspective, this is a step up from Schedule C in one major way: you can use the partnership for advanced strategies like ring-fencing (more on that in a second) and the SALT cap workaround. But you still can’t create earned income for health insurance and retirement benefits—for that, you need an S-Corp.

The Ring-Fencing Strategy (Advanced)

Here’s a problem some traders face: let’s say you day trade Apple and Microsoft options (short-term, high-frequency trades for TTS qualification), but you also hold Apple and Microsoft stock in your personal account as long-term investments.

The IRS might look at this and say, “Wait a minute—you’re trading and investing in the same securities. How do we know which positions are TTS trading positions and which are long-term investment positions? We’re going to reclassify some of your claimed Section 475 ordinary losses as capital losses subject to the $3,000 limitation.”

This is called the “substantially identical positions” problem, and it can torpedo your TTS benefits.

The solution: ring-fencing. You form a partnership (or S-Corp) and conduct all your TTS trading inside the entity. Your long-term investments stay in your personal account. Now there’s a clear legal and tax separation—the entity trades, and you invest. The IRS can’t reclassify because the positions are held by different taxpayers (you individually vs. the partnership entity).

Ring-fencing also prevents permanent wash sale losses between your taxable trading account and your IRA. If you sell stock X at a loss in your taxable account and buy it back in your IRA within 30 days, that’s a permanent wash sale—the loss is gone forever because you can’t adjust the cost basis inside the IRA. With a ring-fencing entity, you can avoid this overlap or use the Mark-to-Market election (which exempts you from wash sale rules) to sidestep the issue entirely.

The SALT Cap Workaround

If you live in a high-tax state—California, New York, New Jersey, Connecticut, Massachusetts—you’re probably getting crushed by the $10,000 SALT (State and Local Tax) deduction cap. You might be paying $15,000, $20,000, or even $30,000 in state income taxes, but you can only deduct $10,000 on your federal return.

Over 20 states have enacted “SALT cap workaround” laws that let pass-through entities (partnerships and S-Corps) pay state income tax at the entity level. The entity gets a deduction for the tax payment (reducing its federal taxable income), and you get a credit on your state return.

Net result: you convert what would have been non-deductible SALT (above the $10,000 cap) into a fully deductible business expense.

This is a huge benefit if you live in a high-tax state and have significant trading income. But it requires a partnership or S-Corp—sole proprietors can’t use this strategy.

Why Partnership Can’t Generate Earned Income

Here’s the limitation: partnerships cannot create earned income from trading profits.

Trading income is classified as “unearned income” (also called net investment income). To fund a Solo 401(k) or take an above-the-line deduction for health insurance premiums, you need earned income—wages or self-employment income from active business participation.

Partnerships can’t pay wages to partners (partners aren’t employees). And trading income doesn’t qualify as self-employment income under IRC Section 1402. So if you need to deduct health insurance or make retirement contributions, you need to jump to an S-Corp, which can pay you a W-2 salary (which is earned income).

Who Should Use Partnership Structure?

A partnership makes sense if:

• You need the ring-fencing solution (overlapping TTS and investment positions)
• You live in a high-tax state and want the SALT cap workaround
• You want pass-through taxation with a more formal structure than Schedule C
• You don’t need health insurance or retirement plan deductions (or you get them from another source, like a spouse’s job)

Skip the partnership if:

• You’re a single trader with no spouse or business partner
• You need to deduct health insurance or fund retirement plans from your trading income (go straight to S-Corp)
• You don’t have overlapping positions or SALT cap issues (an SMLLC or sole proprietorship is simpler)

Option 4: S-Corporation – The Tax Optimization Powerhouse

Here’s where the real tax magic happens. An S-Corporation is far and away the most tax-advantaged structure for profitable traders who need health insurance and retirement plan deductions. It’s also the most complex, the most expensive to maintain, and overkill for anyone making under $75,000 a year.

But if you’re profitable and you qualify? The tax savings are massive.

What is an S-Corp Election?

First, let’s clear up a misconception: S-Corp isn’t a separate type of entity. It’s a tax election you make with the IRS.

You can elect S-Corp status for an LLC or for a traditional corporation. Most traders use an LLC taxed as an S-Corp because LLCs are simpler to form and maintain. You file Form 2553 (Election by a Small Business Corporation) with the IRS within 75 days of forming your LLC, and boom—you’re now taxed as an S-Corp.

From that point forward, your LLC files Form 1120-S (U.S. Income Tax Return for an S Corporation) instead of Schedule C or Form 1065. You become an employee of your own business. You pay yourself a W-2 salary, withhold payroll taxes, and issue yourself a W-2 at year-end just like any other employee.

Any profits above your salary are distributed to you as “shareholder distributions,” which are not subject to payroll taxes.

The Game-Changing Tax Advantage: Salary + Distributions

This is the core of the S-Corp advantage, so let’s break it down with a real example.

Let’s say your net trading income for the year is $120,000. Here’s how the math works:

As a sole proprietor:

• $120,000 in income reported on Schedule C
• No self-employment tax on trading income (trading isn’t SE income under IRC 1402)
• But also no ability to deduct health insurance or fund retirement plans
• No tax optimization possible

As an S-Corp:

• You pay yourself a “reasonable salary” of $70,000 (we’ll explain what “reasonable” means in a second)
• You and the S-Corp each pay payroll taxes on that $70,000: 7.65% FICA (Social Security + Medicare) each = total 15.3%, or about $10,710
• The remaining $50,000 in profits is distributed to you as shareholder distributions
• Distributions are not subject to payroll taxes
• Savings: $7,650 (15.3% of $50,000)

That’s real money. Every single year. And this is just the salary-distribution split—we haven’t even talked about the other S-Corp benefits yet.

What is a “Reasonable Salary” for Traders?

Here’s the catch: you can’t game the system by paying yourself a $20,000 salary and taking $100,000 in distributions. The IRS has a “reasonable compensation” requirement.

According to IRS guidance on S-Corporation compensation, “distributions and other payments by an S corporation to a corporate officer must be treated as wages to the extent the amounts are reasonable compensation for services rendered to the corporation.”

The IRS looks at nine factors to determine what’s reasonable:

1. Training and experience
2. Duties and responsibilities
3. Time and effort devoted to the business
4. Dividend history (distributions)
5. Payments to non-shareholder employees
6. Timing and manner of paying bonuses
7. What comparable businesses pay for similar services
8. Compensation agreements
9. The use of a formula to determine compensation

For full-time day traders, “reasonable” typically falls in the $50,000 to $80,000 range depending on your location and total income. If you’re making $150,000+ in net income, you might justify $80,000-$100,000 in salary.

The key is to stay within industry norms. A trader paying themselves a $25,000 salary on $200,000 of income is begging for an audit. A trader paying $70,000 on $120,000 of income? That’s defensible.

When in doubt, consult with a trader tax CPA. They’ll help you set a salary that maximizes your distributions while staying audit-safe.

Health Insurance Deduction with S-Corp

Here’s a benefit sole proprietors and partnerships can’t touch: above-the-line health insurance deductions.

If you’re self-employed and paying $12,000, $18,000, or even $25,000 per year in health insurance premiums for you and your family, those premiums are a huge expense. As a sole proprietor or partner, you can’t deduct them based on trading income because trading income isn’t earned income.

With an S-Corp, you can.

Here’s the mechanism (it’s a bit quirky, but it works): The S-Corp adds your health insurance premium reimbursements to your W-2 wages (Box 1), but those amounts are not subject to payroll taxes. Then, on your personal Form 1040, you take an above-the-line deduction for those premiums (meaning you deduct them even if you don’t itemize).

Net result: You’re getting a full deduction for your health insurance, and you’re not paying payroll taxes on that portion of your compensation.

For a trader with $20,000 in annual premiums, that’s a $20,000 deduction that you couldn’t take any other way. At a 24% federal tax rate, that’s $4,800 in federal tax savings, plus whatever your state rate is.

Retirement Plan Contributions: Creating Earned Income

Trading income is unearned. You can’t fund a Solo 401(k) with it. But wages from an S-Corp? Those are earned income.

Once you’re paying yourself a W-2 salary, you can establish a Solo 401(k) and make two types of contributions:

1. Elective Deferrals (Employee Contribution):

• 2025 limit: $23,500 (or $31,000 if you’re 50+)
• This comes directly out of your W-2 salary
• 100% tax-deductible
• You can also make Roth contributions (no deduction, but tax-free growth forever)

2. Profit-Sharing Plan (Employer Contribution):

• Up to 25% of your W-2 wages
• Maximum total contribution for 2025: $69,000 ($23,500 elective + $45,500 profit-sharing)
• If you’re 50+, the limit is $76,500 ($31,000 elective + $45,500 profit-sharing)

So if you’re paying yourself a $70,000 salary, you can contribute:

• $23,500 (or $31,000 if 50+) elective deferral
• $17,500 profit-sharing (25% of $70,000)
• Total: $41,000 (or $48,500 if 50+)

That’s a $41,000 tax deduction that a sole proprietor making the same $70,000 can’t touch. At a 24% federal rate, that’s roughly $10,000 in federal tax savings.

The best part? You don’t have to fund the profit-sharing contribution until the S-Corp tax return due date (including extensions—so up to September 15 of the following year). You can wait until December, see if you had a profitable year, and then decide to pay yourself a bonus and fund the retirement plan. If you had a losing year, you don’t pay the bonus or make the contribution.

Additional S-Corp Benefits

Beyond salary-distribution splits, health insurance, and retirement plans, S-Corps also give you:

• Ring-fencing (same as partnerships—segregate TTS trading from investments)
• SALT cap workaround (same as partnerships—deduct state taxes as business expenses)
• 20% QBI deduction if you’ve elected Section 475 Mark-to-Market (TTS/475 income qualifies for the Qualified Business Income deduction under certain income thresholds)

The Drawbacks and Complexity

S-Corps aren’t free money. Here’s what you’re signing up for:

Payroll Requirements:

• You must run payroll—meaning calculating wages, withholding federal and state taxes, withholding and remitting FICA and Medicare, filing quarterly Form 941 payroll tax returns, and issuing annual W-2s and W-3s
• Most traders use a payroll service (Gusto, ADP, Paychex) which costs $500-$1,500/year
• You can also do it yourself with software, but it’s tedious

Corporate Compliance:

• You need to maintain “corporate formalities”—meaning annual meetings (even if it’s just you), written resolutions for major decisions, and separation of personal and business finances
• Mixing personal and business funds can result in “piercing the corporate veil,” which destroys your liability protection

State Fees:

• Some states charge annual franchise taxes or fees on S-Corps
• California: $800 minimum franchise tax
• Delaware: $300 annual tax
• Texas: Franchise tax based on revenue (can be $0 for small operations)
• Many states: $0 or minimal fees

Higher CPA Costs:

• Form 1120-S preparation is more complex than Schedule C
• Expect to pay $1,500-$3,500 annually for S-Corp tax return preparation
• You’ll also need bookkeeping (QuickBooks or similar) to track income, expenses, and payroll

Total annual cost for S-Corp compliance: $2,500-$7,500 depending on your state and whether you outsource payroll and bookkeeping.

When S-Corp Makes Financial Sense

Run the break-even math:

• Annual S-Corp costs: ~$3,000-$5,000 (payroll service, higher CPA fees, state fees)
• Tax savings from salary-distribution split: 15.3% on distributions (so $5,000+ in savings if distributions are $35,000+)
• Tax savings from health insurance deduction: Marginal rate × premiums (so $4,000-$6,000 if premiums are $15,000-$20,000)
• Tax savings from retirement contributions: Marginal rate × contributions (so $8,000-$12,000 if contributing $30,000-$50,000)

The S-Corp pays for itself and generates net savings once your net trading income exceeds roughly $75,000-$100,000, especially if you have health insurance to deduct or retirement contributions to make.

Below $50,000 in net income? The complexity usually isn’t worth it. Between $50,000 and $75,000? It’s a gray area—run the numbers with a CPA. Above $100,000? S-Corp is almost always the right call.

Option 5: C-Corporation – Why Most Traders Should Avoid It

We’re including this section for completeness, but let’s be blunt: C-Corporations are almost never the right choice for day traders.

The C-Corp Tax Problem for Traders

C-Corps are subject to double taxation:

1. The corporation pays a flat 21% federal tax on its profits
2. When you take distributions (dividends), you pay personal income tax on those distributions (15%-20% qualified dividend rate, or up to 37% if non-qualified)

For most businesses, this is manageable because they retain earnings in the corporation to fund growth. But traders? You’re not building inventory or buying equipment. You want to pull your profits out and use them.

And here’s the kicker: if you retain too much profit in a C-Corp without a valid business reason (like building a “war chest” for future investments), the IRS can hit you with a 20% accumulated earnings tax on top of the 21% corporate rate. Good luck convincing the IRS that your trading business needs to retain $500,000 in cash.

The result: you’re paying 21% + 20% + your personal rate on distributions. It’s a tax disaster.

The Rare Case for Dual-Entity Structure

There’s one scenario where C-Corps can work for very high-income traders: a dual-entity structure with a C-Corp management company and an LLC trading entity.

The idea is you set up a C-Corp that provides “management services” to your trading LLC. The C-Corp charges the LLC a management fee (say, $100,000), which is a deductible expense for the LLC. The C-Corp pays the 21% rate on that $100,000, and you can take reasonable compensation from the C-Corp, fund rich employee benefit plans (because C-Corps have better retirement plan options than S-Corps), and strategically manage distributions.

But this is an advanced strategy that only makes sense for traders earning $500,000+ annually. For everyone else, S-Corp is simpler, cheaper, and better.

Why Green Trader Tax and Most CPAs Say No

We’ve consulted with every major trader tax CPA firm in the industry—Green Trader Tax, Trader’s Accounting, and others—and their advice is nearly unanimous: avoid C-Corps unless you’re in the top 1% of earners and have a sophisticated dual-entity plan.

The added complexity, the risk of accumulated earnings tax, and the double taxation simply aren’t worth it for the vast majority of traders.

The Decision Framework: Which Structure is Right for You?

Let’s cut through the theory and give you a practical decision tree.

Decision Tree Based on Income and Goals

If your net trading income is under $50,000:

• Recommendation: Stay a sole proprietor or form an SMLLC only if you need liability protection
• Why: The tax benefits of more complex structures don’t justify the costs and compliance burden

If your net trading income is $50,000-$75,000:

• Recommendation: Consider S-Corp if you have significant health insurance premiums or want to make retirement contributions; otherwise, stick with sole proprietor or SMLLC
• Why: You’re in the gray zone—run the numbers with a CPA to see if S-Corp savings exceed costs

If your net trading income is $75,000-$150,000:

• Recommendation: S-Corp is almost certainly worth it, especially if you have health insurance to deduct or want retirement contributions
• Why: Tax savings will easily exceed $5,000-$15,000 annually, far outweighing the $3,000-$5,000 in annual compliance costs

If your net trading income is $150,000+:

• Recommendation: S-Corp with sophisticated tax planning (ring-fencing, SALT workarounds, max retirement contributions)
• Why: You’re leaving tens of thousands of dollars on the table without proper structuring

Factor 1: Your Net Trading Income

This is the single biggest factor. Entity formation costs money and adds complexity. If you’re not making enough profit to justify the hassle, don’t do it.

Calculate your actual net income (gross profits minus all trading expenses like software, data, education, home office). If that number is under $50,000, you’re probably not ready for an entity. Focus on getting consistently profitable first.

Factor 2: Your Need for Employee Benefits

Do you pay $10,000+ per year in health insurance premiums out of pocket? Do you want to sock away $30,000-$50,000 per year in a tax-deferred retirement account?

If yes, S-Corp might make sense even at lower income levels ($50,000-$75,000) because the health insurance and retirement deductions alone can justify the added cost.

If no (maybe your spouse has great health insurance through their employer, or you’re young and don’t care about retirement yet), you can wait until you’re making $100,000+ before forming an S-Corp.

Factor 3: Your Complexity Tolerance

Are you comfortable running payroll, filing quarterly 941 forms, maintaining corporate records, and managing a more complex tax situation? Or does the thought of that make you want to throw your keyboard out the window?

Some traders are natural organizers and don’t mind the admin work. Others would rather pay a CPA to handle everything. And some are perfectly happy staying simple and leaving a bit of money on the table in exchange for less hassle.

Be honest with yourself. If you’re disorganized and hate paperwork, an S-Corp might create more stress than it’s worth. There’s no shame in keeping it simple with a sole proprietorship or SMLLC until you’re ready (or hire someone to handle the complexity for you).

Factor 4: Your State Tax Situation

If you live in a state with no income tax (Texas, Florida, Nevada, Wyoming, Washington, Tennessee), the SALT cap workaround doesn’t apply to you. That removes one benefit of partnership/S-Corp structures.

If you live in a high-tax state (California, New York, New Jersey, Connecticut) and you’re paying $15,000+ in state income taxes that exceed the $10,000 SALT cap, the pass-through entity SALT workaround alone might justify forming a partnership or S-Corp.

Also consider state-specific costs. California charges $800/year minimum franchise tax for LLCs and S-Corps. Delaware charges $300/year. Many states charge $0-$100. If you’re in California and only making $40,000, that $800 annual fee eats into your profitability. If you’re in Texas (no annual fee), forming an entity is cheaper.

How to Form Your Trading Entity: The Step-by-Step Process

Alright, you’ve decided to pull the trigger. Here’s exactly how to set up your entity, step by step.

Step 1: Confirm Trader Tax Status Eligibility

Before you do anything else, make absolutely sure you qualify for Trader Tax Status. Review your trading activity:

• Are you making 4+ trades per day, 15-20 trades per week, 60+ trades per month?
• Are you trading nearly every market day (75%+ frequency)?
• Is your average holding period 31 days or less?
• Are you spending 4+ hours daily on trading activities?

If you can’t honestly answer “yes” to all of those, forming an entity is premature. Get your trading activity up first, then revisit entity formation.

Remember: The entity doesn’t create TTS. Your trading activity does. Forming an LLC won’t magically make you eligible for business expense deductions if you’re only making 10 trades per month.

Step 2: Choose Your State of Formation

You have two choices: form in your home state, or form in a “business-friendly” state like Wyoming, Nevada, or Delaware.

Here’s the reality: unless you have a very specific reason, form in your home state.

The myth that “forming in Wyoming saves you taxes” is mostly nonsense for small traders. Why? Because of tax nexus. If you live in California and trade from your home office in California, California considers that you’re doing business in California. You owe California income tax regardless of where your LLC is formed.

If you form a Wyoming LLC but live in California, you’ll need to register your Wyoming LLC as a “foreign LLC” doing business in California. Now you’re paying:

• Wyoming formation fee (~$100)
• California foreign LLC registration fee ($70)
• California annual franchise tax ($800)
• Plus you might need a registered agent service in Wyoming ($100-$200/year)

Total: $1,000+ per year, versus just forming in California for $70 + $800 = $870.

When out-of-state formation makes sense:

• You actually move your trading operation to that state (remote trader, nomadic lifestyle)
• You’re forming a holding company that won’t have “business activity” nexus in your home state (rare for traders)
• You’re doing a dual-entity structure with sophisticated tax planning (hire a CPA for this)

For 99% of traders: form in your home state and avoid the headache.

Step 3: File Articles of Organization

Head to your state’s Secretary of State website (or equivalent—in some states it’s called “Department of Corporations” or “Division of Corporations”). You’ll file a form called “Articles of Organization” (for LLCs) or “Articles of Incorporation” (for corporations).

The form is usually 1-2 pages and asks for:

• Your LLC name (must include “LLC” or “Limited Liability Company”)
• Your business address (can be your home address)
• Your registered agent (the person/service that receives legal documents on behalf of the LLC)
• Member/manager information (your name and address)

Filing fees by state (2025 data):

• Lowest: Kentucky ($40), Arizona ($50), Arkansas ($50)
• Average: $132
• Highest: Massachusetts ($520), Illinois ($500)
• California: $70 (but $800 annual franchise tax kicks in)

Most states let you file online, and approval takes 1-5 business days. Some states offer expedited processing for an extra fee ($50-$100).

Step 4: Get Your EIN (Employer Identification Number)

An EIN is like a Social Security number for your business. You need it to open a business bank account, file business tax returns, and hire employees.

Good news: it’s free and takes 10 minutes.

Go to IRS.gov and search “Apply for EIN Online.” You’ll answer a series of questions about your business structure, and at the end, the IRS will give you your EIN immediately. Print or save the confirmation letter—you’ll need it for your bank account.

Step 5: File S-Corp Election (If Applicable)

If you’re electing S-Corp tax status, you need to file Form 2553 (Election by a Small Business Corporation) with the IRS.

Deadline: Within 75 days of forming your LLC (if you’re a new entity) or by March 15 of the tax year for which you want the election to take effect (if you’re an existing entity).

Here’s a critical hack: if you form your LLC late in the year (say, November or December), you qualify as a “new taxpayer” and get a 75-day window to file the S-Corp election for the current year. This is useful if you’ve already made money trading this year and want to capture S-Corp benefits retroactively.

If you miss the deadline, you can sometimes make a late election using IRS Revenue Procedure 2013-30, but it requires a valid reason and specific language on the form. Better to just file on time.

Step 6: Open Business Bank Account

Do not commingle personal and business funds. This is critical for maintaining your liability protection (avoiding “piercing the corporate veil”) and for clean bookkeeping.

Open a separate business checking account in your LLC’s name. You’ll need:

• Your Articles of Organization (showing your LLC is legally formed)
• Your EIN confirmation letter from the IRS
• A driver’s license or personal ID
• An initial deposit (varies by bank—some require $100, some require $0)

Shop around. Business accounts have fees. Compare:

• Monthly maintenance fees ($0-$25/month)
• Transaction limits (some banks charge per transaction after 200-300 per month—matters for active traders)
• Online banking features (real-time transfers, integration with accounting software)

Good options for traders: Chase Business, Bank of America Business, local credit unions (often lower fees).

Step 7: Open Business Brokerage Account

You’ll also need a separate brokerage account in your LLC’s name.

Most brokers support entity accounts (Interactive Brokers, TD Ameritrade, E*TRADE, Schwab). The application process is more involved than a personal account—you’ll need:

• Your Articles of Organization
• Your EIN
• Your Operating Agreement (a document describing how the LLC is managed—most states don’t require this to be filed, but brokers often want to see it)
• Personal information for all LLC members

Tax consideration: If you have existing positions in a personal account, transferring them to the LLC account is considered a sale (triggering capital gains/losses). Most traders start fresh with the LLC account and keep the personal account separate (or close it after selling everything at year-end).

Step 8: Set Up Bookkeeping and Payroll (S-Corp)

If you elected S-Corp status, you need:

Bookkeeping software:

• QuickBooks Online ($30-$60/month) is the industry standard
• Xero ($15-$60/month) is a solid alternative
• Wave (free) works for very simple operations

Track all income (trading gains, distributions) and expenses (software, data, office, payroll). Reconcile your bank and brokerage accounts monthly. At tax time, your CPA will use this data to prepare your 1120-S.

Payroll service:

• Gusto ($40-$150/month depending on features)
• ADP (varies, generally $50-$100/month for very small businesses)
• Paychex (similar to ADP)
• DIY with QuickBooks Payroll (integrated into QuickBooks, ~$50/month)

You’ll run payroll whenever you decide to pay yourself—many traders do one annual payroll in December once they know their profit for the year. The payroll service calculates all withholdings, generates your W-2, and files your quarterly 941 forms.

Annual Compliance Requirements: What You’re Signing Up For

Let’s talk about the ongoing work once your entity is formed. This is the part most articles gloss over, but it’s critical to understand what you’re committing to.

Sole Proprietor and SMLLC Compliance

For sole proprietors:

• File Schedule C with Form 1040 (same tax filing you’d do anyway)
• Track expenses throughout the year
• Total time commitment: 5-10 hours annually (mostly at tax time)
• Total cost: $0 (or $300-$800 if hiring a CPA for tax prep)

For SMLLCs:

• File Schedule C with Form 1040 (same as sole proprietor—disregarded entity)
• File state annual report (if required in your state—usually a 10-minute online form confirming your address)
• Pay annual state fees ($0-$800 depending on state)
• Total time commitment: 6-12 hours annually
• Total cost: $0-$800 state fees + $300-$800 CPA (if using one)

Partnership Compliance

• File Form 1065 (U.S. Return of Partnership Income) by March 15
• Prepare Schedule K-1 for each partner
• File state partnership return (most states require this)
• File state annual report
• Pay annual state fees
• Maintain capital accounts and track partner basis (important if you have losses)
• Total time commitment: 15-25 hours annually (or outsource to CPA)
• Total cost: $1,000-$2,500 for CPA preparation + $0-$800 state fees

S-Corp Compliance

This is the big one. S-Corp compliance is real work (or real money if you outsource everything).

Quarterly:

• Run payroll (if paying yourself throughout the year)
• File Form 941 (Employer’s Quarterly Federal Tax Return)
• Pay withheld payroll taxes

Annually:

• File Form 1120-S (U.S. Income Tax Return for an S Corporation) by March 15
• Prepare Schedule K-1 for each shareholder
• Issue W-2 (Wage and Tax Statement) to yourself and file W-3 (Transmittal of Wage and Tax Statements) with the Social Security Administration by January 31
• File state S-Corp return (most states require this)
• File state annual report
• Pay annual state franchise tax/fees
• Maintain corporate minutes (document annual meetings, major decisions)
• Maintain separation of personal and business finances (no mixing funds)

Total time commitment: 30-50 hours annually if you do everything yourself, or 5-10 hours if you outsource payroll and CPA work

Total cost: $2,500-$7,500 annually:

• CPA for 1120-S preparation: $1,500-$3,500
• Payroll service: $500-$1,500
• Bookkeeping (if outsourced): $500-$1,500
• State fees: $0-$800
• Miscellaneous (registered agent if needed, corporate records software): $100-$500

It’s not cheap, but remember: if you’re making $100,000+ and saving $10,000-$20,000 in taxes, the compliance cost is a bargain.

Common Mistakes to Avoid When Forming a Trading Entity

Our team has seen traders make the same costly mistakes over and over. Learn from their pain.

Mistake 1: Forming an Entity Without TTS

This is the biggest one. You read an article about “tax savings with an LLC,” you get excited, you form an LLC, and then your CPA tells you at tax time that you can’t deduct your trading expenses because you don’t qualify for Trader Tax Status.

Reality check: The entity itself doesn’t grant you tax benefits. TTS grants you tax benefits. The entity just makes it easier to use those benefits (and adds some additional benefits like health insurance and retirement deductions for S-Corps).

Before you form anything, confirm your trading activity qualifies for TTS. If it doesn’t, get your trading activity up first.

Mistake 2: The Wyoming/Nevada Trap

We touched on this earlier, but it’s worth repeating because it’s such a common trap.

New traders read that Wyoming and Nevada have “no state income tax” and “business-friendly LLC laws,” so they rush to form a Wyoming LLC while living in California, New York, or wherever.

Then reality hits:

• You still owe California (or your home state) income tax because you’re doing business there (tax nexus)
• You have to register your Wyoming LLC as a foreign LLC in California ($70 + $800/year)
• You need a registered agent in Wyoming ($100-$200/year)
• You accomplish absolutely nothing except spending more money

Unless you physically move to Wyoming and conduct your trading business there, forming out-of-state is pointless (and expensive).

Mistake 3: Setting S-Corp Salary Too Low

The temptation is real. Why pay yourself a $70,000 salary (and owe 15.3% payroll tax on it) when you could pay yourself $30,000 and take $40,000 more in tax-free distributions?

Because the IRS will audit you, reclassify your distributions as wages, and hit you with penalties and back taxes.

The IRS has clear guidance: you must pay yourself “reasonable compensation” for services performed. For a full-time trader, “reasonable” means looking at what comparable professionals earn. A full-time day trader isn’t a $30,000-per-year employee. You’re more like a financial analyst or portfolio manager, which means $50,000-$80,000 is defensible depending on your location and experience.

Set your salary too low, and you’re inviting an audit. Talk to a trader tax CPA who understands the case law and can help you set a defensible salary.

Mistake 4: Mixing Personal and Business Funds

You form an LLC for liability protection, and then you use your LLC bank account to pay your personal mortgage. Or you transfer money back and forth between personal and business accounts with no documentation.

This is called “commingling funds,” and it can destroy your liability protection. If a creditor ever sues you and can show that you treated your LLC as a personal piggy bank with no real separation, a court can “pierce the corporate veil” and go after your personal assets.

The rule is simple: Business income goes into the business account. Business expenses come out of the business account. If you want to pay yourself, you do it formally (via salary or distribution) and you document it. Never pay personal expenses directly from the business account.

Mistake 5: Missing the S-Corp Election Deadline

You form your LLC on January 15. You think, “I’ll elect S-Corp status when I file my taxes next year.”

Too late. The deadline for S-Corp election is 75 days after formation for new entities, or March 15 for existing entities. If you miss it, you’re stuck as a partnership or disregarded entity for the entire year.

There’s a procedure to make a late election (Revenue Procedure 2013-30), but it requires reasonable cause and additional paperwork. It’s much easier to just file Form 2553 on time.

Set a calendar reminder: 60 days after forming your LLC, file Form 2553 if you want S-Corp status.

Mistake 6: Ignoring State-Specific Rules

Every state is different. Some examples of state-specific quirks that trip up traders:

California:

• $800 annual minimum franchise tax for LLCs and S-Corps (due even if you have zero income)
• Additional 1.5% tax on S-Corp income over certain thresholds
• Strict rules on what qualifies as “doing business” in California

New York:

• LLCs must publish a notice in two newspapers for 6 consecutive weeks within 120 days of formation (the “publication requirement”)
• Cost: $1,000-$2,000 depending on county
• If you don’t comply, your LLC can be suspended

Illinois:

• Annual report fee: $75 for LLCs
• But higher fees for corporations

Texas:

• No state income tax, but franchise tax on revenue (not income) for businesses over $1.23M in revenue
• Most traders won’t hit this threshold, so $0 tax

Before you form an entity, check your state’s specific requirements. Talk to a local CPA or business attorney who knows the rules.

How Entity Structure Integrates With Other Tax Strategies

Your entity choice doesn’t exist in isolation. It’s part of a broader tax optimization strategy that includes TTS qualification, the Mark-to-Market election, business expense deductions, and more.

Entity + Mark-to-Market Election

The Mark-to-Market election under Section 475(f) is a powerful tool that converts capital gains/losses into ordinary income/losses, eliminates wash sale headaches, and removes the $3,000 capital loss limitation.

But there’s a deadline problem: for individuals, the Section 475 election must be filed by April 15 of the current year (for that year’s trades). If you’re reading this in June and want MTM for 2025, you’re out of luck as an individual.

Entity hack: If you form a new LLC or S-Corp mid-year, that entity is considered a “new taxpayer” and gets a 75-day window from formation to elect Section 475 for the current year.

So if you form an LLC on November 1, you have until January 14 (75 days) to file the Section 475 election for the LLC, and that election applies to all the trading done by the entity from November 1 through December 31.

This is one of the most powerful uses of entity formation—rescuing a late-year MTM election.

Entity + Business Expense Deductions

All the usual trading business expenses—software subscriptions, data feeds, home office, education, equipment—are deductible once you qualify for TTS.

But the reporting differs by entity:

• Sole proprietor: Schedule C (straightforward)
• Partnership: Page 1 of Form 1065 (ordinary business expenses), then flow through to K-1
• S-Corp: Page 1 of Form 1120-S (ordinary business expenses), then flow through to K-1

The deductions are the same. The forms are just different.

One nuance: unreimbursed partnership expenses (UPE). If you’re a partner in an LLC taxed as partnership, you can deduct certain expenses (like your home office) as UPE on Schedule E Page 2 if the partnership agreement allows it. This is less formal than an S-Corp, where everything needs to run through corporate records and reimbursement policies.

Entity + Section 1256 Contracts

If you trade futures or broad-based index options (like SPX or NDX), you get the benefit of Section 1256 60/40 tax treatment—60% of your gains are taxed at the lower long-term capital gains rate, 40% at short-term, regardless of holding period.

The good news: Section 1256 treatment applies regardless of your entity structure. Sole proprietor, LLC, S-Corp—doesn’t matter. You still get the 60/40 split.

The even better news: if you’re using an S-Corp and trading Section 1256 contracts, you can stack the benefits:

• 60/40 tax treatment on your trading gains
• Salary-distribution split to save on payroll taxes
• Health insurance and retirement deductions

It’s the best of all worlds for futures traders.

---

When to Hire a Professional (And How to Find the Right One)

Let’s be honest: trader taxes are complex. TTS qualification, Section 475 elections, entity formation, reasonable compensation, retirement plan limits—there are a lot of moving pieces. And the IRS doesn’t publish a simple “how-to” guide for traders (Topic 429 is vague at best).

At some point, you need professional help.

Signs You Need a Trader Tax CPA

You should hire a trader tax specialist if:

• Your net trading income exceeds $75,000 (the tax savings will easily pay for the CPA)
• You’re considering an S-Corp election (this isn’t DIY territory for most people)
• You’re using multiple strategies (TTS + MTM + entity + SALT workaround)
• You’ve received an IRS audit notice or have questions about past returns
• You’re trading across multiple account types (taxable, IRA, entity) and worried about wash sales or overlapping positions
• You simply don’t want to figure this out yourself and would rather pay an expert

The ROI is massive. A good trader tax CPA charges $300-$500 for an initial consultation, $500-$1,500 for entity formation assistance, and $1,500-$5,000 annually for tax return preparation. But they’ll save you $5,000, $10,000, or $20,000+ in taxes through strategies you didn’t even know existed.

What to Look for in a Trader Tax Specialist

Not all CPAs understand trader taxes. Your local CPA who does returns for dentists and small retail shops? They probably don’t know what Section 475 is, and they’ll give you bad advice.

Look for:

• Specialization in trader taxes: They should explicitly say “we work with active traders” on their website
• Knowledge of TTS and Section 475: Ask them directly: “What are the criteria for Trader Tax Status?” and “When should I elect Mark-to-Market?” If they can’t answer immediately, they’re not a specialist
• Entity formation experience: They should be able to explain the S-Corp salary-distribution strategy in plain English and give you a reasonable salary recommendation based on your income
• References from other traders: Check trader forums (Elite Trader, r/Daytrading, StockTwits) and look for recommendations

The Top Trader Tax Firms (Specialists)

These are the nationally recognized firms that specialize in trader taxes:

Green Trader Tax

• Website: GreenTraderTax.com
• Founders: Robert A. Green, CPA
• Specialty: TTS, Section 475, entity formation, all asset classes
• Known for: Comprehensive blog with free resources, annual trader tax guide

Trader’s Accounting

• Website: TradersAccounting.com
• Specialty: Entity structuring, payroll for trading S-Corps, TTS consulting
• Known for: Hands-on entity setup services

Rocket Trader Tax CPA

• Specialty: Trader taxes, entity setup, Section 475 elections
• Known for: Serving traders in major metro areas (LA, NYC, Chicago, Miami, etc.)

All three firms offer consultations. You can also find local CPAs with trader tax experience—just make sure they actually work with traders regularly, not just once or twice a year.

The Cost of Professional Help

Here’s what to expect:

Initial consultation: $300-$500 (1-2 hours)

• They’ll review your situation, confirm TTS eligibility, and recommend an entity structure

Entity formation assistance: $500-$1,500

• They’ll help you form the LLC/S-Corp, file the S-Corp election, set up your EIN, and get everything ready for trading

Annual tax return preparation:

• Sole proprietor / SMLLC: $800-$1,500
• Partnership: $1,500-$2,500
• S-Corp: $2,000-$5,000 (higher because of the 1120-S complexity and payroll forms)

Ongoing advisory: Some firms offer monthly retainer services ($200-$500/month) where you can call with questions year-round

ROI example: You pay $3,000 for S-Corp setup and annual tax prep. The CPA saves you $12,000 in taxes through proper salary structuring, health insurance deductions, and retirement contributions. Net benefit: $9,000. That’s a 3:1 return on your investment.

---

Real-World Cost Comparison: What You’ll Actually Pay

Let’s put real numbers to everything we’ve discussed. Here’s what each structure costs annually, so you can see the break-even analysis clearly.

Sole Proprietor Total Annual Cost

• Formation cost: $0
• Annual state fees: $0
• Tax preparation: $300-$800 (if hiring CPA; $0 if DIY with TurboTax)
• Additional compliance: $0
• TOTAL ANNUAL COST: $300-$800 (or $0 if DIY)

SMLLC Total Annual Cost

• Formation cost (one-time): $40-$500 (depends on state)
• Annual state fees: $0-$800 (California is $800; many states are $0-$100)
• Tax preparation: $300-$800 (same as sole proprietor—still Schedule C)
• Registered agent (if needed): $0-$300
• TOTAL ANNUAL COST: $300-$1,900

Partnership Total Annual Cost

• Formation cost (one-time): $40-$500
• Annual state fees: $0-$800
• Tax preparation (Form 1065 + K-1s): $1,000-$2,500
• Bookkeeping software (QuickBooks): $360-$720/year
• Registered agent (if needed): $0-$300
• TOTAL ANNUAL COST: $1,400-$4,300

S-Corp Total Annual Cost

• Formation cost (one-time): $40-$500
• Annual state fees: $0-$800 (California $800; Texas $0; varies by state)
• Payroll service: $500-$1,500/year
• Tax preparation (Form 1120-S): $1,500-$3,500
• Bookkeeping software (QuickBooks): $360-$720/year
• CPA/bookkeeping consulting: $500-$1,500 (for payroll setup, quarterly check-ins)
• Registered agent (if needed): $0-$300
• TOTAL ANNUAL COST: $2,900-$8,300

Break-Even Analysis: When Does S-Corp Pay for Itself?

Let’s say your S-Corp costs $5,000 annually (middle of the range). When does it make financial sense?

Scenario 1: Salary-distribution tax savings only

• Net income: $100,000
• Reasonable salary: $60,000
• Distributions: $40,000
• Payroll tax savings on distributions: $40,000 × 15.3% = $6,120
• Net savings: $6,120 – $5,000 cost = $1,120 profit

At $100,000 income, you’re barely breaking even. But add health insurance and retirement:

Scenario 2: Salary-distribution + health insurance + retirement

• Net income: $120,000
• Reasonable salary: $70,000
• Distributions: $50,000
• Payroll tax savings: $50,000 × 15.3% = $7,650
• Health insurance deduction: $18,000 premiums × 24% tax rate = $4,320 saved
• Retirement contribution: $40,000 into Solo 401(k) × 24% = $9,600 saved
• Total tax savings: $21,570
• Net benefit after $5,000 cost: $16,570

Now we’re talking. At $120,000+ income with significant health and retirement expenses, the S-Corp is a no-brainer.

Rule of thumb: S-Corp becomes clearly profitable when your net trading income exceeds $75,000-$100,000, especially if you have health insurance to deduct or want to make retirement contributions.

FAQ: Business Entity Setup for Day Traders

The Bottom Line: Entity Structure Is a Lever, Not a Magic Button

Here’s what our team wants you to walk away understanding: your business structure is a tax optimization lever, not a substitute for actual trading skill.

We’ve seen too many traders obsess over LLC versus S-Corp versus partnership while their actual trading strategy is a mess. They’re overtrading, cutting winners too early, letting losers run, and violating every risk management rule in the book. No entity structure can save you from bad trading.

But if you’re consistently profitable, qualified for TTS, and making $75,000+ annually, ignoring entity structuring is like leaving $10,000-$20,000 on the table every year. It’s real money. And it compounds.

Here’s the decision framework one more time, simplified:

Making under $50k/year? Stay a sole proprietor. Focus on getting better at trading.

Making $50k-$75k? Consider an SMLLC for liability protection. Consider S-Corp only if you have big health insurance or retirement expenses.

Making $75k-$150k? S-Corp is almost certainly worth it. The tax savings will dwarf the compliance costs.

Making $150k+? S-Corp with sophisticated planning (ring-fencing, SALT workarounds, max retirement contributions). Hire a specialist CPA—this is their wheelhouse.

And remember: the entity doesn’t create TTS. Qualify for TTS first by establishing substantial, frequent, continuous trading activity. Then use the entity to maximize your benefits.

If you’re ready to take the next step, review our complete guide on Trader Tax Status qualification, understand the Mark-to-Market election if you’re dealing with wash sales, and map out all your deductible trading expenses. These strategies work together as a complete tax optimization system.

Now go make some money. And keep more of what you make.

Article Sources

This article was built on guidance and data from the following high-authority sources:

1. IRS Topic No. 429 – Traders in Securities (Information for Form 1040 Filers)
   • URL: https://www.irs.gov/taxtopics/tc429
   • Official IRS guidance defining Trader Tax Status, Schedule C filing requirements, and Section 475(f) election process
2. IRS – S Corporation Compensation and Medical Insurance Issues
   • URL: https://www.irs.gov/businesses/small-businesses-self-employed/s-corporation-compensation-and-medical-insurance-issues
   • Primary source for reasonable compensation factors, shareholder-employee wage requirements, and health insurance premium treatment
3. IRS Form 1120-S Instructions – Reasonable Compensation Requirements
   • URL: https://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-news/fs-08-25.pdf
   • Official IRS fact sheet detailing the nine factors for determining reasonable compensation for S-Corporation officers
4. Charles Schwab – Mark-to-Market Election and Trader Status
   • URL: https://www.schwab.com/learn/story/mark-to-market-trader-taxes
   • Educational resource from major financial institution covering TTS benefits, MTM election procedures, and business expense deductions
5. LLC University – LLC Filing Fees and Annual Fees by State (2025)
   • URL: https://www.llcuniversity.com/llc-filing-fees-by-state/ and https://www.llcuniversity.com/llc-annual-fees-by-state/
   • Comprehensive state-by-state data on LLC formation costs and annual compliance fees